Repository navigation
docs: remove macOS version-number admission gates - #255
Conversation
Align current ADR 0057 and Watcher admission text to operator clarification 6835298564. Version collection and coverage remain diagnostic/engineering information, not runtime allowlists or version-only warnings. Preserve genuine capability and safety refusals and the completed #252 history. Relates to #172. Co-authored-by: Copilot App <223556219+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com> Copilot-Session: d6ee8a1d-e581-4f6c-a42b-77c84bfccc8b
Keep proc_translated ENOENT distinct from a failed required check, preserve hosted runner and VM eligibility, and distinguish translated detector descendants from runtime/guard translation refusal. Relates to #254 and #172. Co-authored-by: Copilot App <223556219+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com> Copilot-Session: d6ee8a1d-e581-4f6c-a42b-77c84bfccc8b
Verbatim sole-reconciler patch for current canonical admission clauses and the standalone #254 docs node/task. Preserve completed history, #172 ownership/dependencies/checkpoints and the separate MacBook product lane. Relates to #254 and #172. Co-authored-by: Copilot App <223556219+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com> Copilot-Session: d6ee8a1d-e581-4f6c-a42b-77c84bfccc8b
|
Design steward contract review for #254: CLEAR at exact head eb6b802 (base b0d63db). Reviewed against the operator clarification #172 (comment) (8083 bytes, SHA-256 426a96be...) and the #254 spec. This is a contract review only; it is not a merge approval. CI and Campaign's merge gate remain. What I checked:
Non-blocking nit: the Status paragraph of After merge, the #172 body needs the matching ENOENT, hosted-runner and descendant clause, as the #254 spec says. |
Integrate the accepted fixture correction and preserve the landed #259 full-acceptance qualification. Resolve the Watcher graph using the sole canonical author's exact bytes; retain the six-path admission-policy delta. Co-authored-by: Copilot App <223556219+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com> Copilot-Session: d6ee8a1d-e581-4f6c-a42b-77c84bfccc8b
|
Design steward exact-head contract/integration review: PR #255 at 74beab8 (base main 6456d82, tree 3b66b2e08d75b9256a0548fa068b8443efd2b866). Result: CLEAR (contract and integration only; Campaign runs the merge gate; fresh CI is not assessed here). Method: read-only git at the exact SHAs; my own blob, diff and parsed-JSON comparison. No product audit, native run or CI judgment. Checked:
Carried forward (non-blocking, unchanged): the #172 task's "version-range admission below" wording (about L96-97) goes in the #254 completion metadata. The further #172 body ENOENT/hosted/descendant clause follows the confirmed #255 merge. |
|
Merge cleared at 74beab8. Campaign-live gate: merge, high confidence. Fresh Opus 5.5/high preference review of the complete six-file integrated delta is CLEAR, CONSTITUTION no, with no unsettled fork or hard stop. This implements the operator's recorded no-version-number admission gates or version-only warnings; it adds no runtime behavior or claim that all macOS versions work. The fresh exact-head steward contract/integration CLEAR is #255 (comment). The sole canonical author's independent actual-incorporation receipt confirms the ordinary integration preserves #259's metadata and #172's blocked/focus full-acceptance dependency, four completed internal prerequisites, owner and history. Earlier eb6 reviews are not being carried as new-head approval. Live preflight: OPEN, non-draft, CLEAN/MERGEABLE; head 74beab8 and main/base 6456d82, with no main drift. Parsed closing issues list exactly #254. All 25 checks succeeded: CI 43335086666/a1 has 22 successful actual jobs; Watcher Windows archive 43335086668/a1 has three. No unresolved review threads. The source wait is done and its native fallback was cleared. Native expected merge tree is 3b66b2e08d75b9256a0548fa068b8443efd2b866; pairwise merge-tree with current #257 has no conflict. Accepted scope is DOCS #254 only. Current capability, identity, architecture and signal-safety safeguards remain fail-closed with concrete reasons. Conformance remains engineering coverage, version information diagnostic-only. Mac Watcher stays off the next-release path. This is not #172/#257 product acceptance, native conformance, sender/backend parity, #259 implementation assignment, release or shared-install authority. Follow-through after the actual merge: exact-merge main CI and owner closeout; the already-agreed #172 public-body ENOENT/native, hosted-runner/VM and translated-descendant clause; sole-author #254 completion including the retained task admission-wording nit. Preserve all remaining containment, receipt/recovery, descriptor and SQLite/PostgreSQL lifecycle-health obligations under their existing owners and trackers. Campaign will use an ordinary merge guarded to this exact head. No other PR is cleared and post-merge CI is not assumed green. |
Decision
Align current macOS Watcher admission text to the operator's clarification 6835298564: no OS floor, ceiling, per-major, exact-build or UUID admission list, and no warning solely for an older, newer or conformance-unvalidated version. Version collection, value and absence are diagnostic-only; native conformance is engineering coverage, not an admission list. P1 is resolved.
Retain native arm64/x86_64 scope and genuine capability, identity, translation, development/KASAN and signal-safety checks. Actual missing or indeterminate requirements still fail closed with the concrete reason. Explicitly treat proc_translated ENOENT as the native/Intel case; hosted runners and VMs are not admission failures. Runtime/guard checks do not refuse translated detector descendants as group members.
Scope and consequence
Consequence: normal. This docs-only alignment records already-published operator direction; it does not change runtime behavior or assert that every macOS version works. Current macOS Watcher remains unshipped/fail-closed, off the next-release path and separate from ordinary macOS Telex build/install/upgrade coverage.
Owner edits are limited to ADR 0057's heading, dated clarification and current admission text, plus the Watcher admission paragraph and its direct anchor. Canonical current admission text is incorporated exactly from the sole reconciler; no independent canonical edit or historical-record rewrite is included. The accepted Ended predicate, residual, recovery and implementation safeguards are unchanged.
The early #172 body admission alignment was accepted by the steward; the matching ENOENT/native/hosted clause will be added to that body after this docs PR merges. The Campaign-owned decision supplement is unchanged.
The existing MacBook agent remains the only product implementation lane and need not wait for this docs item. Probe exactness, boot UUID, inherited descriptors/SIGCHLD, late cleanup/receipt recovery, the private-ABI wording and pipe-holder behavior remain obligations of that product lane, not a new audit here.
Review and disposition
Fresh steward contract review is required at the integrated head; ordinary CI and Campaign's merge gate remain. No new product issue, writer, native run, kernel proof, release or shared installation is authorized. The policy change corrects current documentation's superseded admission rule. Historical acceptance and records stay intact.
Integration and head-bound evidence
Ordinary merge head
74beab86b1df834aec6b28cb21fffc04a4328787has parentseb6b802813ec52b2f51bcdc213e9521a2ff08f40and current main6456d828a18105c6fc9991cca1220a5318eb7363, which contains the accepted #256 fixture correction. No rebase or independently authored fixture repair is included here. The PR delta from that main remains exactly the six policy-doc/canonical paths.The sole reconciler supplied the exact Watcher graph conflict resolution. The complete merged tree is
3b66b2e08d75b9256a0548fa068b8443efd2b866, matching the reconciler's manifest. Landed #259 metadata, #172's blocked/focus qualification for full acceptance, its pending external Local bootstrap-identity edge, four completed internal dependencies, owner and historical records are preserved. Independent containment development, reviews and App preparation remain separate from that full-acceptance dependency.The earlier steward CLEAR covers only
eb6b8028, not this changed head. Fresh exact-head review, CI, preference assessment and Campaign gate are required. No merge clearance is claimed.Original CI
43306999770, attempt 1, ended with 17 successful and 5 failed jobs. The macOS cap-setup refusal, three fixture-resolution failures and fifth Windows build failure remain recorded. No old-head retry was dispatched, no failure is waived, and neither those original jobs nor the upstream PR's checks substitute for this integrated head's CI. Campaign retains CI wait coordination.Historical contract provenance: #165.
Closes #254
Relates to #172